Short vs Long Form Advisor
Describe your video idea. We return a verdict (Short, Long, or Both — repackage), with reasoning and a predicted view-count range per platform. Considers niche density, payoff structure, and search-vs-discovery fit.
What's different here: Most "short vs long" advice is opinion. We score the idea against three structural axes that predict format fit.
Verdict will appear here.
What this solves
A 90-second video can become a 6-minute long-form, or it can stay short. Knowing which is the right move for your idea saves hours of editing.
How to interpret
"Short" means the idea fits a 60-sec payoff. "Long" means it requires 5+ minutes. "Both" means reframe: short for discovery, long for trust.
FAQ
When is short always wrong?
When the idea requires building context (e.g. a long coding tutorial). Shorts can't carry setup.
Can I just cut my long-form into Shorts?
You can, but Shorts from long-form underperform Shorts designed natively. The structure is different.